Why a Hidden Discount Converts Better Than a Big One
Make buyers curious, and they’ll make the purchase
This is the 442nd consecutive post on MrEmogical Notes. If you’ve been following this series and are finding value from this blog/ newsletter, please consider sharing this post with one person who you feel needs to read this for their betterment.
Introduction
Most businesses overcomplicate marketing.
They chase trends, fancy funnels, complex automations, and endless hacks.
But sometimes, the most powerful strategy is also the simplest one, and this clever email experiment proves it.
A major brand recently ran a marketing test that shows how deeply our buying decisions are shaped by psychology, not logic.
Their insight? A tiny shift in messaging can completely flip conversion rates. Not because of bigger discounts, but because of mystery, curiosity, and behavioral commitment.
This is how mystery discount marketing works, and how you can use it too.
The simple experiment that beat a bigger discount
The brand divided its entire customer base into two segments and sent the exact same email to each group.
There was just one difference:
Group A: “You get a special 15% discount today.”
Group B: “You get a special discount today.” (Percentage not revealed)
Everything else was identical.
Same subject line. Same layout. Same CTA. Same offer. Only one line of text changed.
And the results? The mystery discount email crushed the clearly stated discount email.
Group B not only clicked more. They bought far more. Let’s unpack why.
The psychology behind the mystery
Humans don’t like suspense. We crave closure. We want to know the answer, and when the brand said:
“You get a special discount,” but didn’t reveal how much. It triggered a powerful psychological loop: I must find out.
This is called the Zeigarnik Effect. The brain’s tendency to seek completion of incomplete information.
The only way for Group B to “complete the loop” was to visit the website.
So they did, in far bigger numbers.
The hidden genius: Behavioural investment
Here’s where it gets even smarter. Once someone clicked through, curiosity alone wasn’t enough. They still didn’t know the discount.
So what did they do?
- They browsed the website
- Shortlisted items
- Added products to their cart
- Applied the coupon code
Only then did they discover the truth:
It was the same 15% discount Group A already knew about.
Now here’s the twist:
Even though the discount wasn’t bigger, Group B still purchased more.
Why? Because they had already invested: time → effort → attention → emotional energy.
This is called Commitment & Consistency Bias. Once we start a process, we feel compelled to complete it.
By the time they reached the checkout, the discount amount didn’t matter.
What mattered was:
“I’ve already done the work… I might as well buy.”
And that’s why mystery discount marketing outperformed the explicit discount email.
Why the mystery discount worked better than a clear 15% off
Let’s break it down simply:
- Mystery creates curiosity
- Curiosity drives clicks
- Clicking leads to browsing
- Browsing leads to cart additions
- Cart additions lead to psychological commitment
- Commitment triggers completion
- Completion converts into sales
Group A saw 15% off upfront. There was no emotional investment. No journey. No curiosity loop.
The deal was instantly judged: “worth it” or “not worth it.”
Group B only learned it was 15% at the very end, after doing the work, and by then, they were already mentally “in.” That’s buyer psychology at work.
How to use mystery discount marketing in your business
You can apply this idea in multiple ways:
01 - Mystery discount code email
Instead of: “Flat 20% off today,” Try: “Your special discount is unlocked. Click to reveal.”
02 - Exit intent mystery pop-up
Instead of: “Wait! 10% off.” Try: “Spin the wheel to reveal your secret discount.”
03 - Mystery offer on product pages
Instead of: “Buy now, 15% off.” Try: “An exclusive discount is waiting for you at checkout.”
04 - Mystery bundle upgrade
Instead of: “Upgrade for ₹999.” Try: “Your upgrade price is unlocked at checkout.”
The idea is simple: Curiosity → Engagement → Commitment → Conversion.
As long as the reward isn’t disappointing, this strategy consistently outperforms plain discounts.
Why this works so well
The mystery discount strategy works because it aligns with three universal truths:
01 - People hate uncertainty enough to take action to remove it.
02 - People value what they invest effort into.
03 - People feel compelled to complete what they start.
You’re not manipulating the customer. You’re working with natural human psychology. That’s what smart marketing is.
Food for thought
This brand didn’t increase ad spend. They didn’t create a complex funnel. They didn’t design a new offer. They simply changed one line in an email, and that was enough to significantly increase sales.
Marketing isn’t always about doing more. Sometimes it’s about doing something unexpectedly simple, but psychologically powerful.
Use this strategy in your next campaign. Test it. Measure it. Then share your results. You might be surprised how much “mystery” can move your revenue.
LEARN HOW MARKETING REALLY WORKS
If you’ve been wanting to elevate your knowledge of business positioning, funnel marketing, and brand building, it’s time to take the next step.
Attend The Brand Marketing Masterclass. A 90-minute live training designed to help you attract your ideal audience, structure your funnel strategically, and transform your brand into a powerful conversion system.
It’s completely free for now, but seats are limited, and this might not stay free forever.
REGISTER NOW to claim your spot before the batch fills up.Your views?
If you’ve reached till this point of the post, I’m sure you must have some thoughts/ feelings/ opinions about what you’ve just read.
I’m done sharing what’s on my mind, and now is your turn to share your POV.
Tell me how you are processing the information that you’ve just read?
Do you agree with my thoughts?
Do you think I missed something important?
Do you disagree with something in particular?
Let’s continue this conversation (or ask your questions about the post) in the comments below.
Keep Going Keep Growing 🚀
Have I earned your share?
Thank you for reading the full post. Since you read this till the end, it’s safe to assume you found value in the content.
Please consider sharing this post with your audience on social media. You may end up helping someone who’s struggling in their career/ business because they don’t understand the importance of building their personal brand.
I’m sure if you think hard, you will easily come with a few names who you know must read this.
Share this with them, help them, and earn your blessings.
Prompt used to create the image for the note
P.S.: Image made on Meta AI using the prompt, “Create an image of a shopper at a laptop applying a “mystery discount code” at checkout, with curiosity and anticipation on their face. Use warm lighting, clean e-commerce visuals, and a horizontal 16:9 layout with negative space for title overlay. No text, logos, or watermarks. --stylize 210”